31 December 2014

Liverpool v Leicester 01.01.15

10am ET, live in the US on NBC Sports Live Extra

Last four head-to-head:
3-1 Liverpool (a) 12.02.14
0-0 (a) 03.28.04
2-1 Liverpool (h) 09.20.03
1-0 Liverpool (h) 01.30.02

Last three matches:
Liverpool: 4-1 Swansea (h); 1-0 Burnley (a); 2-2 Arsenal (h)
Leicester: 1-0 Hull (a); 1-2 Tottenham (h); 0-2 West Ham (a)

Goalscorers (league):
Liverpool: Lallana, Own Goal, Sterling 4; Gerrard 3; Coutinho, Henderson, Moreno 2; Can, Johnson, Lambert, Skrtel, Sturridge 1
Leicester: Ulloa 7; Cambiasso, Mahrez, Schlupp 2; Nugent, Vardy, Wood 1

Referee: Mike Jones

Guess at a line-up:
Mignolet
Can Toure Sakho
Henderson Gerrard Lucas Moreno
Coutinho Lallana
Sterling

I'm afraid I've got some bad news.

That XI which was so much fun on Monday? It's gonna be a different XI tomorrow.

Skrtel's suspended, which means Lovren (if fit) or Toure's coming back into the side. That shouldn't preclude Liverpool playing three at the back, but it'll be interesting to see who the sweeper is with Skrtel missing. Not that Skrtel's a bastion of positional integrity, but neither Lovren nor Toure is known for their discipline, to say the least. Gerrard will also return after being rested, which means Henderson will either shift to wing-back or Lucas will be dropped. Moreno may keep his place, but I wouldn't be surprised to see Markovic back either.

I expect Liverpool to stick with the 3-4-3. With nine days until the next league match – albeit with the FA Cup trip to Wimbledon on Monday – I expect the front three to remain the same for at least one more match. I expect Liverpool to press and counter and be the better side, as they're at Anfield, but I don't expect as much fun as Monday was either. But maybe this season just has me even more jaded than usual.

Leicester remain at the bottom of the table, three points behind Burnley, Palace, and Hull, but they're coming off their first win since September 21, winning 1-0 at Hull on Sunday. A Hull side that Liverpool failed to beat at Anfield, I'll churlishly add.

Leicester have a fairly small squad, but there will be at least a couple of changes from the side which lost to Liverpool a month ago. Schmeichel is injured, Konchesky is suspended. Andy King, who didn't feature in the last meeting, is also out. Danny Simpson's been preferred to Ritchie de Laet at right-back in recent matches. Ulloa, Leicester's top scorer by some distances, actually seems the most likely candidate to be rested now that Vardy's back from suspension. But I still expect the XI to be familiar, a 4-4-2/4-4-1-1 formation with something like Hamer; Simpson, Wasilewski, Morgan, Konchesky; Mahrez, James, Cambiasso, Schlupp; Ulloa, Vardy.

Leicester will sit even deeper than they did at home, with two solid banks of four, and dare Liverpool to carve them open. Swansea started similarly on Monday, but Liverpool's pressing and movement disjointed then broke those lines by the 33rd minute, and those lines were a moot point by the 51st. Can Liverpool do that again? Leicester blocked 45.5% of Liverpool's shots in the reverse fixture; only Chelsea, Sunderland, and Burnley have blocked a higher proportion of Liverpool's shots this season.

Simply put, Liverpool need to continue firing on all cylinders, and even with changes to the XI, need to put in a performance reminiscent of that on Monday. Prove that it wasn't a fluke. Prove that you weren't just playing up to the opposition's level, and the side's now better than the one which lost at Palace, drew against Hull and Sunderland, barely beat QPR, Burnley, and Stoke.

Begin to prove that the first half of 2015 will be more like the first half of 2014, even if Liverpool fail to hit those heady heights, and not like the second half of 2014.

30 December 2014

Visualized: Liverpool 4-1 Swansea

Previous Match Infographics: Burnley (a), Arsenal (h), Manchester United (a), Basel (h), Sunderland (h), Leicester (a), Stoke (h), Ludogorets (a), Crystal Palace (a), Chelsea (h), Real Madrid (a), Newcastle (a), Hull (h), Real Madrid (h), QPR (a), West Brom (h), Basel (a), Everton (h), West Ham (a), Ludogorets (h), Aston Villa (h), Tottenham (a), Manchester City (a), Southampton (h)

As always, match data from Stats Zone, except shot location from Squawka and average player position from ESPN FC.


(Nota Bene: Here's the formation diagram usually included in match reviews.)

I love it when a plan comes to fruition.

One swallow certainly doesn't make a summer, and Liverpool fans have more than a little experience with false dawns and turning points that weren't actually turning points, but I'd like to give Brendan Rodgers some credit after that.

People were rightfully questioning almost every move he made earlier this season. Liverpool were bad. Very bad. From early September through November, with few signs of positivity even when Liverpool won. But the switch to 3-4-2-1 was a surprise gamble that's slowly paying off. Not many managers would have the gumption to change formations, especially to that formation rarely seen in England, and especially when Liverpool are playing two matches a week, with much less training time than the side had last season.

Sure, some of Rodgers' choices have been forced. Do we see Can and Sakho at center-back if Johnson and Lovren don't get injured? Do we see Sterling up front if Balotelli isn't injured, then suspended (as was Borini)?

But that's football, I guess. Better to be lucky than good, even better to be lucky and good.

We'd already seen signs of progress. Liverpool had been better in pretty much every regard since the switch to 3-4-2-1, even if results didn't immediately follow. The only match where Liverpool didn't improve was the match at Burnley, which Liverpool still won. And I'll note that Burnley side came back from a 2-0 deficit to draw at Manchester City two days later, making Liverpool's result look a bit more impressive even if the performance certainly wasn't.

But yesterday was the first time that everything clicked. Yesterday was the first time since Sturridge's injury that this season's Liverpool actually resembled last season's Liverpool.

Despite conceding possession to Swansea, Liverpool never conceded the initiative. Swansea had the ball, but had few dangerous attacks.

Liverpool pressed, hassled, and harried Swansea. Liverpool's top four tacklers were the two wide attackers and the two wing-backs.

Liverpool successfully played a high defensive line, and Liverpool coped with Bony far better than they did in last season's 4-3. With Can and Sakho, Liverpool had two defenders capable of playing out from the back. Yes, Sakho made two mistakes in quick succession – one costly, one not – but the one which led to the goal wasn't a mistake like those hands-over-face ones we've seen earlier this season; he won a contentious aerial duel but couldn't direct the header out, with Sigurðsson smart enough to gamble by running into space and getting rewarded for it. And Sakho also started the opening goal with a perfect long pass to Moreno and did this. Capable of great and terrible, Mamadou Sakho is large, Mamadou Sakho contains multitudes. Which is better than being capable of just terrible (*glares at unnamed defender*).

And Liverpool were dangerous on the counter, for only the third or fourth time this season; Coutinho, Lallana, and Sterling linking up better than they ever had. Funny how that works with increased time together. All three attackers took at least four shots, all three put at least 40% of their shots on target, with two of Sterling's three off-target shots hitting the woodwork.

Two of Liverpool's goals came from quick attacks starting in their own half, one came from Lallana's pressing (albeit coupled with Fabianski's horrendous mistake), and one came from a set play. That sounds an awful lot like how last season's goals came. And Liverpool's best counter didn't even lead to a goal. Had that gone in, we could end the goal of the season contest now.

Yesterday saw Liverpool's highest shot accuracy of the season: 52.4%, 11 of 21. Liverpool scored four goals for the first time this season. I suspect those two stats are related. 10 of Liverpool's shots came in the Danger Zone, 16 of Liverpool's shots came down the center of the pitch. That's the result of good build-up play and good decisions from the attackers.

As against United and Arsenal, Liverpool still allowed Swansea too many Danger Zone shots, seven of their 11 in the six-yard box or center of the 18-yard box. But the only two on-target aside from Sigurðsson's too-easy goal were easily handled: tame headers from Dyer and Bony. Aside from that goal, none of Swansea's chances were especially high-value, even if the location was dangerous.

The goals are finally starting to come, the mistakes are lessening in defense, the team is actually starting to look like a team. Yes, it's just one match, but it bodes better than anything we've seen so far this season. Now Liverpool have to do the same at Anfield in three days time, against the bottom side in the division. Two swallows are a step closer to signifying the summer.

Goodbye and good riddance, 2014. Hello, 2015.

28 December 2014

Liverpool v Swansea 12.29.14

3pm ET, live in the US on NBC Sports

Last four head-to-head:
2-1 Liverpool (h; League Cup) 10.28.14
4-3 Liverpool (h) 02.23.14
2-2 (a) 09.16.13
5-0 Liverpool (h) 02.17.13

Last three matches:
Liverpool: 1-0 Burnley (a); 2-2 Arsenal (h); 3-1 Bournemouth (a)
Burnley: 1-0 Villa (h); 1-0 Hull (a); 1-2 Tottenham (h)

Goalscorers (league):
Liverpool: Sterling 4; Gerrard, Own Goal 3; Coutinho, Henderson, Lallana 2; Can, Johnson, Lambert, Moreno, Skrtel, Sturridge 1
Swansea: Bony 8; Dyer, Ki, Routledge, Sigurðsson 3; Gomis, Shelvey 1

Referee: Andre Marriner

Guess at a line-up:
Mignolet
Toure Skrtel Sakho
Henderson Gerrard Lucas Moreno
Coutinho Lallana
Sterling

Brad Jones' injury means that Mignolet will have to come back into the side, no matter how Rodgers wants to handle the goalkeeping situation (read: horror show). Regardless of how long Jones is out, Liverpool simply have to buy a keeper in the upcoming window, but that's neither here nor there tomorrow. Mignolet has a couple of matches to prove he was worth the transfer, to prove he has any sort of future at Liverpool, and has to take advantage.

Otherwise, I don't know how much Rodgers will rotate the side. You'd think there would have to be some, but Rodgers often subscribes to the 'if it ain't broke' theory, especially when the side's eking out positive results.

At least one of Gerrard or Lucas seem most in need of a rest, but Lucas has become crucial to this formation – despite his faults, no other midfielder is as good at protecting the space in front of the center-backs – and Gerrard remains Gerrard. Markovic was below par at Burnley compared to his performances in the previous two matches, so Moreno could come into the side. Can did well in the second half against Burnley, and could keep his place in defense, while Lovren should be fit again soon, possibly in time for tomorrow's match.

The one area where I'd be surprised to see changes is up front. Sterling, Coutinho, and Lallana are starting to click as a unit. Both Balotelli and Lambert would slow down the attack, which is the trio's greatest strength. That Liverpool are at home should mean more pressing up front, something neither striker is well equipped for, although both have "tried" to fill that role more than at their previous clubs. And I'd be very surprised if Liverpool switched away from the 3-4-2-1 formation.

Swansea will have revenge on their minds tomorrow. For the late League Cup loss, for last season's pulsating 4-3. It doesn't hurt that Swansea and Liverpool are next to each other in the table, with three points separating the two sides.

And there are also a few players with a point to prove against Liverpool. First and foremost, Jonjo Shelvey, but also Wilfred Bony – rumored to be a major target both last summer and in the future – and Gylfi Sigurðsson, who turned down Liverpool in the summer of 2012 to join Tottenham. And Swansea are still a side packed with players from Brendan Rodgers' tenure as manager.

As with Liverpool, I'm not sure how much Swansea will rotate. The first-choice XI would be Fabianski; Rangel, Fernandez, Williams, Taylor; Ki, Shelvey; Dyer, Sigurðsson, Routledge; Bony. But that's pretty much the same XI which played on Boxing Day save for Montero, who's out with a hamstring injury. But Richards could come in at right-back, Bartley in central defense, Tom Carroll in midfield (as could Britton, who'll have to pass a late fitness test), Emnes on the left or up front, or Gomis up front. But I suspect, as with Liverpool, it'll be as near to full-strength as possible.

Liverpool finally won a close away match while keeping a clean sheet on Boxing Day. Against Bournemouth and Arsenal, Liverpool demonstrated a bit of potency which had been sorely lacking too often this season. Now, Liverpool need to combine those facets, to put together a comprehensive performance. They'll be aided by being at Anfield, where they've been marginally better this season.

Because Liverpool will need a comprehensive performance to beat Swansea, a side much more potent than Burnley and slightly more secure at the back than Arsenal. This will be one of Liverpool's more difficult matches during this crucial festive schedule, and they simply have to rise to the occasion.

27 December 2014

Visualized: Liverpool 1-0 Burnley

Previous Match Infographics: Arsenal (h), Manchester United (a), Basel (h), Sunderland (h), Leicester (a), Stoke (h), Ludogorets (a), Crystal Palace (a), Chelsea (h), Real Madrid (a), Newcastle (a), Hull (h), Real Madrid (h), QPR (a), West Brom (h), Basel (a), Everton (h), West Ham (a), Ludogorets (h), Aston Villa (h), Tottenham (a), Manchester City (a), Southampton (h)

As always, match data from Stats Zone, except shot location from Squawka and average player position from ESPN FC.


(Nota Bene: Here's the formation diagram usually included in match reviews.)

Aside from Liverpool's general insipidness and frequently awful play, that was just how Rodgers' drew it up. Somehow keep a clean sheet, then a sucker punch counter-attack featuring Coutinho's guile and Sterling's speed.

It was like Hull (h) and Sunderland (h), except that Liverpool actually scored from its solitary moment of class.

It was like Stoke (h), a narrow win thanks to a second half goal, with Liverpool disjointed, subpar, and second-best for long stretches, except Liverpool got that second half goal with 30 minutes left to play, not needing a late flurry and able to ride the match out fairly easily.

It was like Newcastle (a), except for that Liverpool goal, and also keeping the opposition from getting one of their own.

It was like QPR (a) and Leicester (a) in that Liverpool didn't impress in the slightest against not-very-good opponents, but still won because of the opposition's failings. Unlike in the QPR match, Liverpool didn't fall apart at the end, requiring the late flurry. Unlike Leicester, Burnley couldn't take advantage of Liverpool's worst defensive mistake, Ings' shot ricocheting off the post and away instead of in off the keeper's back, And at the same time, QPR and Leicester's defenses are much, much worse than Burnley's.

It was a bit like Palace (a), except Burnley couldn't put a single shot on target, let alone five. Which was incredibly helpful so thank you very much, Burnley.

Yes, we've seen this movie before. At least parts of it. And Liverpool played different styles and formations in each of those matches. 4-1-2-3 against Sunderland, Leicester, and Hull. 4-2-3-1 against Stoke, Newcastle, and QPR. 4-4-2 diamond at Palace.

So maybe it's not the formation that's the problem.

After seemingly turning the corner in regards to shot disparity in the last three matches (four if you count Bournemouth), Liverpool once again registered fewer shots than their opponents. Yesterday's 10 was the second-lowest total of the season, behind the six at Newcastle. Meanwhile, Burnley were allowed 16. But none were on target (thanks again, Burnley!), and unlike against United and Arsenal, only six of those 16 were in the box, just four of those 16 in the Danger Zone (six-yard box and center of the 18-yard box). If you're gonna allow too many shots, it's slightly better if they're not high value shots.

But at the same time, only four of Liverpool's ten came inside the box, only two in the Danger Zone. Yikes.

Liverpool's last eight goals – every goal since Can against Chelsea – have come in the Danger Zone. 42 of Liverpool's 110 shots in those six matches have come in the Danger Zone – 38%, which is the exact same proportion as last season. But last season Liverpool had Suarez and Sturridge, able to score from almost any position on the pitch. Without those players, Liverpool are much more reliant on high value shots, and Liverpool aren't getting enough high value shots.

But some of that seemed tactical. It helps explain why only four players registered shots: the three attackers and one of the two wing-backs. Away from home, Liverpool went back to playing for the counter, especially for the first hour, often with seven or eight or more players in their own half. That seems to be asking for trouble given that a) Liverpool have been pretty terrible on the counter this season and b) Liverpool frequently give away cheap goals when the opposition has the opportunity to attack at will. It's probably not coincidence that Liverpool have been pretty terrible away from home this season. I thought we were passed this since the switch to 3-4-2-1. Liverpool did not play this way in away matches at United or Bournemouth.

Yesterday also saw Liverpool's lowest passing percentage of the season – 77.8% – slightly behind Stoke (h) and QPR (a). For once, it wasn't because of inept passing in the final third. That wasn't great – 67%, a touch below average – but it wasn't West Ham (a), Newcastle (a), Palace (a), or Stoke (h) either. Liverpool's failures were primarily in midfield and defense. Lucas (-4.9%), Gerrard (-2.8%), Henderson (-11.5%), Markovic (-5.1%), Sakho (-7.3%), Skrtel (-5.4%), and Toure (-24%) were all well below their season-long passing accuracies. And it's no coincidence that the vast majority of Burnley's tackles and interceptions came in the middle third of the pitch.

It's news to no one that taking the game to Liverpool and that pressing Liverpool often leads to rewards. Liverpool survived yesterday, Liverpool survived against QPR and Leicester – primarily due to those teams' failings – but West Ham, Newcastle, and Palace (among others) still loom large in the memory. Again, that the majority of those aforementioned games came away from Anfield suggests that Liverpool's tactics on the road also have something to do with Liverpool's issues.

But that middle third pressure meant Burnley ran out of gas in the last half an hour, and Liverpool took advantage with a moment of brilliance from Sterling and Coutinho (notably, his first Premiership assist of the season, but to be fair, he only had one at this point last season and finished the season with seven).

To be honest, that's acceptable given where Liverpool are at the moment. The underlying stats still aren't great, the tactics have often disappointed, but the recent results have been even worse. This is the first time that Liverpool have won 1-0 away from home, a single goal and clean sheet, since beating Villa in August 2013. 55 league matches ago. It's more valuable that Liverpool are able to grind out a win, even if they were helped by the opposition's failings, rather than playing well in a draw (Arsenal) or loss (United).

But the majority of the division is better than Burnley is, and they'll be much more likely to take advantage if Liverpool play like this.

25 December 2014

Liverpool at Burnley 12.26.14

10am ET, live in the US on NBC Sports Live Extra

Last four head-to-head:
4-0 Liverpool (a) 04.25.10
4-0 Liverpool (h) 09.12.09
0-1 Burnley (a, FA Cup) 01.18.05
1-0 Burnley (h, FA Cup) 01.04.97

Last three matches:
Liverpool: 2-2 Arsenal (h); 3-1 Bournemouth (a); 0-3 United (a)
Burnley: 1-2 Tottenham (a); 1-0 Southampton (h); 0-2 QPR (a)

Goalscorers (league):
Liverpool: Gerrard, Own Goal, Sterling 3; Coutinho, Henderson, Lallana 2; Can, Johnson, Lambert, Moreno, Skrtel, Sturridge 1
Burnley: Ings 4; Barnes 3; Boyd 2; Arfield, Kightly, Wallace 1

Referee: Anthony Taylor

Guess at a line-up:
Jones
Toure Skrtel Sakho
Henderson Gerrard Lucas Markovic
Coutinho Lallana
Sterling

If it ain't (all that) broke, don't fix it.

Same formation, same XI seems the most likely outcome tomorrow. Because Liverpool's actually been decent, and slowly improving – slowly looking like the Liverpool we remember – when doing so. If Lovren's fit, maybe he comes in for Sakho. I'm still hopeful, but not expecting, that Mignolet will replace Jones. Balotelli's fit and back from suspension, but is more likely to appear as a substitute. There's always the option of replacing Lucas or Gerrard with Allen or Can, Markovic with Moreno or Enrique, as Liverpool have three matches in six days, but I suspect we'll see more rotation on Monday rather than tomorrow.

And Liverpool's 3-4-2-1 set-up matches up well against Burnley's usual 4-4-2. Sometimes it's 4-3-1-2, sometimes 4-4-1-1, but often an orthodox 4-4-2. And Burnley, with one of the smallest squads in the league, rotate infrequently, especially since they've few injuries at the moment. The best guess is the same XI which narrowly lost to Tottenham last weekend: Heaton; Trippier, Keane, Shackell, Mee; Boyd, Marney, Jones, Arfield; Barnes, Ings.

Burnley have been a better side since Ashley Barnes came into the starting XI, losing just two of their last seven matches after finally winning their first on November 8. Burnley remain goal-shy, yet to score more than twice in any match this season, but they've been held scoreless just once during the last seven matches, and both Ings and Barnes have notched recently, and are capable of creating their own opportunities or setting up others. And Burnley have also become more secure at the back, yet to allow more than two goals during this seven-match run.

Tomorrow is either the end of the beginning or the beginning of the end for Liverpool. With matches against Burnley (18th), Swansea (8th), Leicester (20th), Sunderland (14th), and Villa (12th) in the next three weeks, Liverpool have a chance to make up ground in the table, to make amends for the previous few months.

If it were only that easy. Liverpool have demonstrated an unwelcome ability to play down to the level of their opposition too often this season, especially when away from Anfield. Newcastle, West Ham, and Palace – three debilitating losses – all quickly come to mind.

Tomorrow is Liverpool's next chance to change that trend. They won't have many more.

22 December 2014

Visualized: Liverpool 2-2 Arsenal

Previous Match Infographics: Manchester United (a), Basel (h), Sunderland (h), Leicester (a), Stoke (h), Ludogorets (a), Crystal Palace (a), Chelsea (h), Real Madrid (a), Newcastle (a), Hull (h), Real Madrid (h), QPR (a), West Brom (h), Basel (a), Everton (h), West Ham (a), Ludogorets (h), Aston Villa (h), Tottenham (a), Manchester City (a), Southampton (h)

As always, match data from Stats Zone, except shot location from Squawka and average player position from ESPN FC.


It's a very small sample size, but there has been a noticeable difference in Liverpool's attacking output since the switch to 3-4-2-1.



I'm using the match at Villa as the beginning of the comparison, as that was Liverpool's first match without Sturridge.

Unfortunately, that improvement in attacking output hasn't translated into goals. Liverpool averaged slightly more than a goal per game between in the 12 matches between Villa (h) and Sunderland (h); Liverpool's averaging a goal per game in the last two matches, with two against Arsenal and none against United.

But, yes, there has been a vast improvement in the underlying shot statistics. Not only in total output, but location. In that earlier 12-match stretch, 50% of Liverpool's shots came inside the box, 28.4% in the Danger Zone (six-yard box and center of the 18-yard box). In the last two matches, it's 54.3% in the box and 43.5% in the Danger Zone. You'd have to believe that the goals will come if Liverpool can continue this output.

But then there are matters at the other end of the pitch.



Liverpool are allowing fewer shots, but more are on-target. And there are a lot more goals. In those 12 earlier matches, Liverpool's opponents averaged 9.33 shots per goal. In the last two matches, it's 3.6 shots per goal.

That's bad. That's very, very bad. United and Arsenal are better in attack that almost every opponent Liverpool faced during that 12-match stretch except for Chelsea, but that's still a damning indictment of both Liverpool and Brad Jones.

In Jones' defense, Liverpool are allowing those shots in more dangerous positions. During that 12-match stretch, 50.7% of the opposition's shots came inside the box, 31.4% in the Danger Zone. In the last two matches, it's 61.1% in both the 18-yard box and the Danger Zone; every single shot that United and Arsenal took inside the penalty box came in the Danger Zone. That's a recipe for disaster. Liverpool are not helping Brad Jones, but Jones also isn't helping himself.

Liverpool's 32 successful tackles were the most this season, the most since the 3-2 win over Norwich last April. Liverpool 64.7% possession was the third highest total of the season, behind Aston Villa (h) and Hull (h), two opponents nowhere near as capable as Arsenal are.

On the whole, Liverpool fared better than they usually do against Arsenal, last season's 5-1 home win not withstanding.



At home under Rodgers, Liverpool had won 5-1 and drawn 2-2. Liverpool lost both matches at the Emirates two goals to none. For the most part, yesterday's statistics were slightly better than we'd seen in previous against Arsenal, and the result wasn't out of the ordinary either. Which, again, is an improvement on Liverpool's recent form.

So yes, we saw some better from Liverpool. There are signs for optimism, signs this side can get its act together. The next five matches should be a lot easier than the previous two.

But we also saw the result ruined by the same problems that've have plagued the side all season: defensive issues on set plays and counters, and Liverpool's ability to convert its chances.

21 December 2014

Liverpool 2-2 Arsenal

Goals:
Coutinho 45'
Debuchy 45+2'
Giroud 64'
Skrtel 90+7'

Ridiculous Liverpool is more enjoyable than boring Liverpool but this team's still not good enough. Liverpool did a lot of good things, but Liverpool only drew 2-2 – and were lucky to do so – because Liverpool is still Liverpool.

Liverpool took 27 shots. Arsenal took seven. This match finished 2-2, and only because Liverpool finally scored from their 10th corner in the 97th minute, their first goal from a corner this season.

Brad Jones has faced nine shots on target in the last two matches. Brad Jones has allowed five goals. He wasn't the only Liverpool player at fault for either goal – as usual, we've a few scapegoats to choose from – but both of Arsenal's goals should have been saved: late to react to the first, the second scored between his legs.



That's the short version of this match. There's more to it, but that's enough of a summary as to why Liverpool's only taking one point instead of all three.

Some credit where it's due. Rodgers' change to 3-4-2-1 has made Liverpool a better side. The first half seemed as close to Rodgers' "death by football" ideal that we heard so much about when he became Liverpool manager as we've seen since he became Liverpool manager. Liverpool monopolized possession – I doubt Arsenal's been held to 34.6% possession in one half very often in the last decade or so – and Liverpool looked reasonably secure. Arsenal were bereft of opportunities, Alexis Sanchez rendered a non-factor. Liverpool passed the ball out of defense surprisingly well, nullifying any Arsenal pressing.

But until Coutinho struck in the 45th minute, Liverpool had few chances of their own. Eight first half shots prior to the goal, but only Gerrard's 22-yard free kick sailing wide and Szczesny's stop on Markovic in the 35th minute were memorable. Then, the breakthrough: Liverpool's pressure forcing a mistake from Arsenal, Henderson's quick pass to Coutinho – who often found acres of space – at the top of the box, stepping around Debuchy before hammering into the far corner. Liverpool deserved as much for their first half play, and it seemingly came at the perfect time.

But because Liverpool are still Liverpool, they gave Arsenal the goal right back. Arsenal attack from the kick-off, and Sanchez wins a free kick off Gerrard that was barely a foul. Liverpool had three chances to clear, but Mertesacker beat Toure and Sakho in the air, Flamini beat Lucas in the air, and Debuchy beat Skrtel in the air while Brad Jones remained rooted to his goal line and slow to react. Sigh.

The second half began in a similar manner as the first: good Liverpool possession and build-up but a dearth of Liverpool chances – the best from a ball over the top to Sterling, rounding the on-rushing Szczesny but pushed wide of goal, his cross to an open Gerrard headed narrowly over. And then Liverpool were ruthlessly punished on the break. A low percentage Hollywood pass by Gerrard easily picked off, Gibbs in acres of space down Liverpool's right with Henderson caught upfield, a centering pass to Giroud, a quick pass to Cazorla, a cutback back to Giroud, who'd somehow found space between Skrtel and Sakho. Still, Jones could and should have stopped the shot, sent straight at him, directly through his legs. Sigh.

And thus began Liverpool's "onslaught," with Arsenal happy to protect an undeserved lead. So many shots from distance. So many shots deflected or blocked, often falling tamely for Szczesny rather than a fortunate redirection into the net. Borini and Lambert on for Markovic and Toure, Liverpool first switching Sterling to wing-back, then shifting to 4-4-2 with Henderson and Sterling as the full-backs in-name-only. Until Liverpool finally Szczesny forced into a difficult save in the 85th minute, parrying Borini's header from Sterling's cross over the bar, Liverpool's best chance came from Lucas – of all people – a late run into the box ending with his left-footed shot whistling just wide of the post.

It appeared all over when Borini was sent off at the beginning of injury time. He deserved both yellows – the first for dissent, the second for a high boot that tore Cazorla's kit – but the first yellow only came about because of an incorrect decision from Oliver and his linesman. And that Flamini remained on the pitch after two yellow-card worthy fouls in the first half rubbed extra salt in the wound.

Still, Liverpool pressed, and Liverpool finally got the late equalizer, in the depths of an especially long extra time because of an earlier head injury to Skrtel. So it was fitting that Skrtel, wrapped in a black bandage just as he was in this fixture last season, scored the equalizer. Arsenal's marking on the corner was as terrible as Liverpool's on the equalizing free kick in first half injury time: Skrtel allowed a free run and free header to Coutinho's cross, bulleted into the net. I'm told that was Liverpool's 127th corner of the season. Not a bad time to finally score from one.

It's also fitting that a late equalizer parallels the result from 2010-11, another late Liverpool equalizer in extra-long injury time. This season's had a lot of similarities with 2010-11, especially Liverpool's points total, even though the overall play has been more reminiscent of 2011-12 and 2012-13.

With better finishing, Liverpool wins 4-1 or 4-2. With better defending and/or a better goalkeeper, Liverpool wins 2-0 or 2-1. And it's especially regrettable because Liverpool desperately needed all three points. One's obviously better than none – and feels much, much better than none – but one barely helps Liverpool's league position.

But a month ago, Liverpool loses this match 1-2 or 0-2. It has been a slow, painful process, but Liverpool are improving, especially in possession and in chance creation. As against Bournemouth, Markovic was impressive as a wing-back (he and Sakho did so well against Alexis that the Chilean went over to the opposite flank in the second half), Lallana and Coutinho were dangerous (this was Coutinho's best game in quite some time), and Lucas and Gerrard were actually okay in midfield.

But Liverpool are not improving enough, not improving fast enough, not enough to paper over the massive weaknesses still present at both ends of the pitch.

20 December 2014

Liverpool v Arsenal 12.21.14

11am ET, live in the US on NBC Sports

Last four head-to-head:
1-2 Arsenal (a; FA Cup) 02.16.14
5-1 Liverpool (h) 02.08.14
0-2 Arsenal (a) 11.02.13
2-2 (a) 01.30.13

Last three matches:
Liverpool: 3-1 Bournemouth (a); 0-3 United (a); 1-1 Basel (h)
Arsenal: 4-1 Newcastle (h); 4-1 Galatasaray (a); 2-3 Stoke (a)

Goalscorers (league):
Liverpool: Gerrard, Own Goal, Sterling 3; Henderson, Lallana 2; Can, Coutinho, Johnson, Lambert, Moreno, Sturridge 1
Arsenal: Alexis 9; Giroud 4; Cazorla, Ramsey, Welbeck 3; Chambers, Koscielny, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Özil, WIlshere 1

Referee: Michael Oliver

Guess at a line-up:
Jones
Toure Skrtel Sakho
Henderson Gerrard Lucas Markovic
Coutinho Lallana
Sterling

I'd be fairly surprised if it's not the same formation and XI as against Bournemouth. Lovren's doubtful, so Sakho seems likely to start, but that seems the only alteration.

The biggest difference of late is that the 3-4-2-1 has actually been fun. Sure, Liverpool are still leaking goals – United scored three, Bournemouth could have easily scored three had they taken their chances – but Liverpool somehow look competent in attack, scoring three good goals on Wednesday, creating a hatful of good chances that they should have taken against United.

It's last season's philosophy rediscovered, if to a much lesser extent due to personnel. But it's a start. Quick attacks, clever interplay, and constant movement from the front players. Lallana and Markovic were both outstanding on Wednesday, Sterling looked increasingly comfortable (and took him chances) up front, and Henderson also did well as a right wing-back. Nonetheless, Arsenal will have chances.

While Markovic was excellent against Bournemouth, at least going forward, I worry about his defensive duties against Arsenal. More specifically, against Alexis Sanchez. Bournemouth's best chances came down Liverpool's left, Bournemouth's goal started down Liverpool's left, and that's where Alexis will be playing. Moreno's pretty much a defender in name only at this point as well, while Jose Enrique remains Jose Enrique, so maybe being as proactive as possibly and hoping to pin Alexis back, with Sakho and Lucas helping to cover when he gets forward, is the best option.

Also, Liverpool's midfield will continue to make me quite nervous. Gerrard and Lucas paired always makes me nervous, but Gerrard-Allen wasn't any better against United and Henderson's needed as the wing-back (especially with Johnson injured). Can seems an option in this formation due to his versatility, whether in midfield, at left wing-back, or left-sided center-back, but I suspect if he's used, it'll be off the bench.

Liverpool's aren't overflowing with other options. 4-2-3-1, 4-3-3, and 4-Diamond-2 have all looked inferior, no matter personnel. Balotelli's suspended, which means that Sterling pretty much has to start up front, whether on his own or partnered with Lambert. Flanagan and Suso are back in training, but not yet fit enough to feature. Johnson will be out for a while, Sturridge is still a few weeks away at best.

I would suggest one other change. Please bring back Mignolet. I understand why Rodgers has dropped the Belgian for the last two games; Mignolet hadn't been anywhere near his best, and like City did with Joe Hart last season, Rodgers is trying to remove him from the firing line while he figures out what the hell's gone wrong. But Brad Jones is worse. Significantly worse. He was at fault for none of them, but Jones could and should have done better on all four goals Liverpool have conceded in the last two games.

Currently sixth in the league, five points ahead of Liverpool, Arsenal are once again very Arsenal. Dangerous up front, if sometimes unable to take advantage of excellent scoring moves and opportunities. Often held together with duct tape in midfield and defense, still lacking an out-and-out defensive midfielder, and frequently riddled with injuries.

And, as usual, Arsenal have even more injury concerns than Liverpool do. Ramsey, Wilshere, Özil, Koscielny, Rosicky, and Arteta will all miss out, while Oxlade-Chamberlain, Monreal, and Walcott are questionable.

Other than Chambers returning from suspension, tomorrow's XI will probably look the same as that which beat Newcastle 4-1. Szczesny; Debuchy, Chambers, Mertesacker, Gibbs; Oxlade-Chamberlain, Flamini, Cazorla; Alexis, Giroud, Welbeck. That front three is incredibly threatening, especially the aforementioned Alexis, while both Giroud and Cazorla are in goal-scoring form.

But whether Chambers or Monreal partners Mertesacker, Arsenal will have to play at least one fullback at center-back, as they've done often this season. It'll be up to Liverpool to exploit it through pace and movement from the front three. And if Oxlade-Chamberlain's also unable to start, Arsenal's other injuries will require either Gideon Zelalem or Francis Coquelin to start in midfield.

You're going to hear an awful lot about Liverpool's 5-1 win in last season's fixture tomorrow. Arsenal will be thinking about it. Liverpool will be thinking about it. And tomorrow's match will probably be defined by Arsenal's reaction to it.

If they're tentative, with that match weighing heavily in the memory, Liverpool have the potential to take advantage thanks to the rediscovered attacking form and Arsenal's makeshift defense. But if Arsenal are determined to make amends, determined to take the game to Liverpool from the opening whistle, and have learned from last season's mistakes, the home side could be in for a very long match.

This is the first match in a very important festive schedule, the first of five in 15 days. If Liverpool win, they'll only be two points behind Arsenal, with winnable matches against Burnley, Swansea, Leicester, Sunderland, and Villa to come over the next month. The 5-1 win over Arsenal last season marked the start of Liverpool's long winning streak, a victory which nearly propelled them to an unlikely title.

But if Liverpool lose, that eight point gap will feel like 20, Liverpool will remain mired in the bottom half of the table for at least another week, and fourth place will seem an impossibility, even with 22 games still to play.